“Looks fine” famous last words

video preview

Hey Reader,

I read a lot of copy.

Home pages, sales pages, about pages, blog posts.

Critiquing messaging & copy for Expert Up Club members is basically a core part of my week. I know what works and what doesn't.

And I've noticed something: AI copy has gotten good enough that people are stopping at the shitty first draft.

Because it looks pretty good. It's professional, hits the right beat, and sounds specific enough.

So I decided to run an experiment.

I gave AI a good prompt, real niche, real offer, real client, and let it write a full homepage.

It produced something that looked pretty good.

Here's the thing about pretty good, especially if you're selling to organizations or to real humans who live outside the online business bubble: pretty good is the most expensive kind of copy you can publish.

There were three specific places this homepage failed in ways most people would never catch before hitting publish.

I broke it down in a new video.

video preview

Watch it here →

AI can do a lot of great things.

It can automate the tedious stuff, slay overthinking, and get you to a shitty first draft fast.

What it can't replace is your taste and discernment.

Without that, you end up with copy and messaging that sounds exactly like everyone else who does what you do.

It produces the average of the average.

If you're done settling for pretty-good messaging, it's time to join the Expert Up Club. I'm booking tours now.

Stop settling for mediocre by booking a tour of the Club.

Yours in rebellion,
Michelle

❗️Don't Miss This❗️

Five private tours are open for The Expert Up Club.

Book one and join the Club before the end of May, and I'll add a bonus triage session with you in your first 30 days.

One hour. You bring the asset that's actively costing you leads — the sales page that gets traffic but not clients, the homepage that isn't converting, the offer that people can't quite explain to anyone else.

We dig into exactly what's wrong with it, what it should be saying instead, and you leave with the words to fix it. Not months from now. Now.

Five Three spots. End of May deadline.

Book your private tour →


What's Up?

Second Week of May 2026

🤔

What I'm Working On

Duped is BACK!

This time, we are diving into why we trust influencers over experts and the cult of Amanda Frances (of Real Housewives fame) and the worship of wealth.

Guess which episode was mine? LOL

🪩

What I'm Excited About

We had the best guest expert session with Devin Lee.

She shared how to make coffee chats lead somewhere. The key to success is not what you think.

It's for Club members only...but you can join us now and check it out.

♥️

What I'm Loving

We saw Cabaret on the big screen this past week.

And the end of it is hard, here's why.

(Also, is Sally Bowles the original manic pixie dream girl?)

Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Sign up for Make Marketing Suck Less: https://drmichellemazur.com/newsletter

Dr. Michelle Mazur

Message Strategist & Founder of The Expert Up Club

YouTube / 3 Word Rebellion Book

Make Marketing Suck Less

Marketing strategies for solo business owners who sell outside the online business bubble. Messaging and marketing for consultants, service providers, and experts whose clients live in the real world—where funnels don't work and referrals matter more than reels.